Glass Nickel Pizza Menu

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Glass Nickel Pizza is a casual dine-in restaurant located in Madison, WI, offering a variety of options including salads, pizzas, sandwiches, and appetizers. With vegan options and a full bar available, it caters to a diverse range of preferences. Customers have praised the quality of the ingredients used in their dishes, highlighting the freshness and flavorful combinations. Positive reviews mention the perfectly cooked pizzas, delicious appetizers like cheese bread and mac and cheese bites, and excellent customer service. While some customers have experienced minor issues with order accuracy, the overall consensus is that Glass Nickel Pizza delivers delicious food with a friendly atmosphere. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or wanting to try something new like the Chicky Chicky Parm Parm, Glass Nickel Pizza is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts.

Appetizers and Sides Specialty Salads The Salad Bar Build Your Own Pizzas Specialty Pizzas Specialty Gluten-Free Pizzas Pocket Pizzas Pasta Subs Chicken Desserts Beverages Sauces/Dressings

Appetizers and Sides

Cheese Bread

Served with a side of marinara.
$9.35

Spinach Cheese Bread

Served with a side of marinara.
$9.35

Garlic Bread Sticks

Served with a side of marinara
$7.90

Nickel Nuggets

Served with a side of marinara.
$7.90

French Fries
$3.40

White Cheddar Cheese Curds
$10.15

Tots

Tater tots
$5.70

Fried Mac and Cheese Bites
$10.15

Jalapeno Poppers with Cream Cheese
$10.15

Mozzarella Sticks

Served with a side of marinara.
$9.00

Fried Mushrooms

Served with a side of ranch.
$8.25

Toasted Cheese Ravioli

Served with a side of marinara.
$9.00

Side Salad

House mix, carrots, cucumbers, red cabbage and tomatoes.
$6.50

Onion Rings

Served with ketchup.
$6.75

Garlic Toast

2 slices toast.
$3.40

Kettle-Cooked Chips
$2.00

Dipping Sauces
$1.45

Gluten Free Cheese Bread

Served with a side of marinara.
$13.30

Gluten Free Spinach Cheese Bread

Served with a side of marinara.
$13.30

Acropolis Salad

Romaine, feta, black olive, red onions, red peppers and tomatoes.
$7.90

Caesar Salad

Romaine, Parmesan, croutons and add your choice of chicken or anchovies.
$11.25

Club Salad

House mix lettuce, bacon, turkey, cheddar and tomato.
$11.25

Garden Salad

House mix lettuce, carrot, cucumber, green pepper, red cabbage, red onion and tomato.
$7.90

Popeye Salad

Spinach, egg, mushroom and red onion.
$7.90

Bac-N-Bleu Salad

Spinach, bacon, bleu cheese, red onion and walnut.
$9.00

Chef Salad

House mix lettuce, ham, turkey, bacon cheddar, carrots, eggs and tomatoes.
$11.25

Cobb Salad

Romaine, chicken, bacon, eggs, cheddar, tomatoes and avocados.
$11.25

Build Your Own Salad

Your choice of greens plus up to four toppings.
$0.00

Specialty Salads

Build Your Own Pizzas

Cheese Pizza
$11.30

10" Cheese Gluten-Free Pizza
$15.30

Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

Classic Italian sauce, house blend cheese, beef, bacon, yellow onions and cheddar.
$15.85

Boarls Karloff Pizza

3 Boar's Head brand meats: Genoa salami, pepperoni, capicola ham with banana peppers, tomatoes, 5 blend cheese, herbs and spices on a base of garlic and olive oil.
$15.85

Border to Border Pizza

Spicy classic Italian sauce, house blend cheese, tomato, pineapple, Canadian bacon and jalapeno.
$15.85

Breakfast Pie Pizza

Fresh scrambled eggs, cheddar cheese, breakfast sausage, bacon, green peppers, yellow onions and tater tots.
$15.85

Buffalo Nickel Pizza

Choice of a tangy bleu cheese or ranch dressing, Buffalo chicken tenders (tossed with franks red hot, fresh garlic and cilantro), celery, cheddar, and house blend cheese.
$15.85

Cardiac Arrest Pizza

Classic Italian sauce, extra house blend cheese, bacon, ham, pepperoni and sausage.
$15.85

Chicken Alfredo Pizza

Creamy Alfredo sauce, house blend cheese, chicken, spinach, garlic and mushroom.
$15.85

Chicky Chicky Parm Parm

Alfredo sauce, house blend cheese, chicken strips, basil, garlic topped off with classic sauce, oregano and Parmesan cheese.
$15.85

Chicken Cordon Bleu Pizza

Honey mustard sauce, house blend cheese, chicken strips, ham and Swiss.
$15.85

Couch Potato Pizza

Classic Italian sauce, house blend cheese, broccoli, bacon, tater tots and cheddar cheese. Served with a side of sour cream.
$15.85

Deluxe Pizza

Classic Italian sauce, house blend cheese, pepperoni, sausage, green pepper, yellow onion and mushroom.
$15.85

Feta-licious Pizza

Chunky marinara sauce, house blend cheese, tomatoes, mushrooms, red onions, spinach and feta.
$15.85

Mac Daddy Pizza

Alfredo sauce, special 5 cheese blend and cavatappi noodles topped with our crispy parsley shake.
$15.85

Margherita Pizza

Ricotta Sauce, house blend cheese, tomatoes, basil and garlic.
$15.85

Mediterranean Pizza

Pesto, house blend cheese, black olives, tomatoes and feta.
$15.85

Pollo Diablo Pizza

Spicy ranch Sriracha sauce, house blend cheese, chicken, bacon, jalapenos and red onions.
$15.85

Portabella Lugosi

Classic Marinara, Portabella Mushrooms, Sausage, Red Onions, Basil, Toasted Garlic, and Mozzarella topped with our Cheese & Herb Shake.
$15.85

The Ranch Pizza

Ranch dressing, house blend cheese, bacon, chicken, red onion and tomato.
$15.85

Santa Fe Pizza

BBQ sauce, house blend cheese, chicken, red onion, red pepper and cilantro.
$15.85

Thai Pie Pizza

Thai peanut sauce, house blend cheese, chicken, broccoli, red peppers, yellow onions and cilantro.
$15.85

Vegg-Out Pizza

Classic Italian sauce, house blend cheese, black olives, broccoli, green peppers, red onions, mushrooms and tomatoes.
$15.85

Sacre Bleu Pizza

Classic sauce topped with house blend and bleu cheese, Canadian bacon, salami, tomato and yellow onion.
$15.85

The David

Toppings: spinach artichoke sauce, house blend cheese chicken and tomatoes
$0.00

Hawaii Pie-O

Classic sauce, canadian bacon, pineapple chunks, yellow onions, red peppers & banana peppers with crispy bacon and house blend cheese.
$15.85

Vegan Pad Thai Pie

Peanut sauce with cilantro, daiya vegan cheese, tofu, broccoli, carrots, red pepper, and yellow onion.
$15.85

Vegan Delight

Bbq sauce, broccoli, pineapple, red pepper, red onion and garlic.
$15.85

Specialty Pizzas

Specialty Gluten-Free Pizzas

10" Bacon Cheeseburger Gluten-Free Pizza

Classic Italian sauce, house blend cheese, beef, bacon, yellow onions and cheddar.
$19.85

10" Boaris Karloff Gluten-Free Pizza

3 Boar's Head brand meats: Genoa salami, pepperoni, capicola ham with banana peppers, tomatoes, 5 blend cheese, herbs and spices on a base of garlic and olive oil.
$19.85

10" Border to Border Gluten-Free Pizza

Spicy classic Italian sauce, house blend cheese, tomato, pineapple, Canadian bacon and jalapeno.
$19.85

10" Breakfast Pie Gluten-Free Pizza

Fresh scrambled eggs, cheddar cheese, breakfast sausage, bacon, green peppers, yellow onions and tater tots.
$19.85

10" Cardiac Arrest Gluten-Free Pizza

Classic Italian sauce, extra house blend cheese, bacon, ham, pepperoni and sausage.
$19.85

10" Couch Potato Gluten-Free Pizza

Classic Italian sauce, house blend cheese, broccoli, bacon, wedge fries and cheddar cheese. Served with a side of sour cream.
$19.85

10" Deluxe Gluten-Free Pizza

Classic Italian sauce, house blend cheese, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, yellow onions and mushrooms.
$19.85

10" Fetalicious Gluten-Free Pizza

Chunky marinara sauce, house blend cheese, tomatoes, mushrooms, red onions, spinach and feta.
$19.85

10" Margherita Gluten-Free Pizza

Ricotta sauce, house blend cheese, tomatoes, basil and garlic.
$19.85

10" Mediterranean Gluten-Free Pizza

Pesto, house blend cheese, black olives, tomatoes and feta.
$19.85

10" Portabella Lugosi Gluten-Free Pizza

Classic marinara, portabella mushrooms, sausage, red onions, basil, toasted garlic and mozzarella topped with our cheese and herb shake.
$19.85

10" Santa Fe Gluten-Free Pizza

BBQ sauce, house blend cheese, chicken, red onion, red pepper and cilantro.
$19.85

10" Vegg-Out Gluten-Free Pizza

Classic Italian sauce, house blend cheese, black olives, broccoli, green peppers, red onions, mushrooms and tomatoes.
$19.85

10" Cheeseasaurus Pizza with Gluten-Free Crust

Sauceless pizza with extra spices, extra house blend cheese and your choice of 4 toppings. Served on a 10" gluten free crust.
$19.85

10" Sacre Bleu Pizza with Gluten-Free Crust

Classic sauce topped with house blend and bleu cheese, Canadian bacon, salami, tomato and yellow onion. Served on a 10" gluten free crust.
$19.85

10" Hawaii Pie-O Gluten-Free Pizza

Classic Sauce, Canadian Bacon, Pineapple Chunks, Yellow Onions, Red Peppers & Banana Peppers with crispy Bacon and House Blend Cheese.
$19.85

10" Vegan Delight Gluten-Free Pizza

BBQ Sauce, Broccoli, Pineapple, Red Pepper, Red Onion and Garlic.
$19.85

Calzone

A generously portioned pocket pizza filled with ricotta, house blend cheese and your choice of 2 toppings. Served with a side of chunky marinara.
$14.70

Stromboli

A generously portioned pocket pizza filled with classic Italian sauce, house blend cheese and your choice of 2 toppings. Served with a side of chunky marinara.
$14.70

Pocket Pizzas

Pasta

Mix N Match Pasta

Choose your favorite noodle and sauce combination from below.
$11.25

Mac and Cheese

Cavatappi noodles, creamy alfredo sauce, Monterey jack and sharp cheddar cheese, salt and pepper.
$14.15

Chicken Alfredo

Creamy Alfredo sauce and oven roasted chicken on a bed of fettuccine.
$14.15

Meat Lasagna

Layers of noodles, ricotta, mozzarella, tomato sauce, mushrooms, tomatoes, yellow onions, ground beef and Italian sausage.
$14.15

Ravioli

Choose from cheese or beef with your choice of sauce. Served with garlic bread.
$9.45

Build Your Own Sub

Can be served cold or hot.
$10.15

Bomber Hot Sub

Meatballs, marinara, mozzarella and Parmesan cheese.
$10.15

Carolina Club Hot Sub

Sliced chicken, bacon, Swiss, tomato, 1000 Island dressing with a side of coleslaw.
$11.25

Chelsea's Choice Sub

Artichoke heart, red onions, tomatoes, banana peppers, feta and fat-free sun-dried tomato dressing.
$8.75

Chicken Cordon Bleu Hot Sub

Chicken strips, ham, Swiss and honey mustard.
$11.25

Chicken Parmesan Hot Sub

Chicken strips, marinara, mozzarella and Parmesan cheese.
$10.15

Cod Hot Sub

Beer battered fish fillets, cheddar, lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce.
$9.25

Hot Wing Hoagie

Chicken strips, cheddar, lettuce and hot Buffalo sauce.
$10.15

Hot Veggie Sub

Broccoli, red peppers, black olives, mushrooms, marinara and mozzarella.
$10.15

Pepperoni Pile On Hot Sub

Pepperoni, mozzarella, marinara and banana peppers.
$10.15

Santa Fe Hot Sub

Chicken, BBQ sauce, red peppers, red onions, jalapenos and cheddar.
$10.15

Shrimp Po Boy Hot Sub

Beer battered shrimp, lettuce, tomatoes and Cajun remoulade.
$10.15

Smothered Chicken Hot Sub

Chicken, spinach, mushrooms, red onions, mozzarella, tomatoes and mayo.
$10.15

BLT Cold Sub

Bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
$10.15

Chef's Club Cold Sub

Turkey, ham, Swiss, cheddar, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, mayo and french dressing.
$11.25

Humongous Hummus Cold Sub

Hummus, tomatoes, cucumbers, spinach and green pepper.
$7.75

Italian Sub

Capicola ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo and italian dressing.
$10.15

Tasty Turkey Cold Sub

Turkey, cream cheese, jalapenos and red onions.
$7.75

Turkey Club Sub

Turkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$12.40

Vegg Head Cold Sub

Cream cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, spinach and avocados.
$7.75

Build Your Own Vegan Sub

Hot or Cold
$10.15

Build Your Own Veggie 1 Chz/5 top

Can be served cold or hot.
$10.15

Build Your Own Veggie 2 Chz/ 3 Top

Can be served cold or hot.
$10.15

Subs

Chicken

Beer Battered Fish Basket

2 fillets served with fries and coleslaw.
$11.95

12 Wings (Bone In)

By the dozen.
$21.50

Chicken Strips Basket

Served with fries and choice of sauce on the side.
$11.30

Big Cookie
$3.15

Cheesecake
$9.65

Cinna-nuggs
$7.90

Pastries
$4.95

Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream

1 pint.
$9.65

Desserts

Beverages

12 oz. Can Soda
$1.70

2 Liter Soda
$4.55

Bottled Water
$2.30

Pure Leaf Lemon Iced Tea
$5.40

Milk

White or Chocolate
$1.90

Pure Leaf Raspberry Iced Tea
$5.40

Pure Leaf Unsweetened Iced Tea
$5.40