• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Glass Nickel Pizza

Glass Nickel Pizza is a vibrant and inviting eatery in Madison, WI, offering a tantalizing menu that includes delicious pizza, fresh salads, and mouthwatering sandwiches. With options for delivery, takeout, and reservations, this restaurant caters to every dining preference. The diverse range of appetizers and sides, such as cheese bread, tater tots, and fried mac and cheese bites, set the stage for a memorable culinary experience. Customer reviews rave about the perfectly cooked pizza and delightful cinnamon nuggets, showcasing the high quality ingredients and exceptional service. This establishment truly embodies the essence of a cozy, casual dining experience with a focus on exceptional pizza.

Glass Nickel Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

JJ S.
JJ S.

Perfectly cooked pizza and downright delectable cinna nuggets! My son and I ordered to our hotel, and while there was a slight delay in the delivery, we would definitely order again!

Heidi S.
Heidi S.

I have no words for this, but, DELICIOUS!!! Their pizza gives me happiness and I love it. Excellent ingredients and tops for delivery and temperature!! This pizza is what I dream of, A must have!!!

Kong L.
Kong L.

I haven't had pizza this good in ages! The ingredients were incredibly fresh, and the crust was perfect. This place brought back so many good memories. It's like stepping back in time!

Scott G.
Scott G.

Had Glass Nickel while traveling. Good pizza. Very much a college-town type pizza but good nonetheless. Will order from them again.

Tina H.
Tina H.

I have had a 75% success rate with my orders being correct here, but the pizza is really good, order comes out on time, and the appetizers not bad so I keep coming back. Tried a new pizza for Pi Day and tried the Chicky Chicky Parm Parm. Wanted it to be thin crust but it came out regular. Oh well, maybe next time it will be correct. Good amount of sauce and the chicken fried up nicely on the cheesy topping. I usually order The Carnivore --that is a top notch pizza. And the Mac and Cheese Pizza isn't bad either but I don't come here for that one. The mac and cheese bites I also tried were good, but not my top choice (the ravioli bites are better). Overall, I will keep coming because I love their pizza sauce, they use good ingredients, and the staff is friendly.

Corey C.
Corey C.

The pizza here is fire. Good crust, great cheese pull, tasty toppings. Their beer selection is good with plenty of eclectic options and a smattering of mainstream boring beers to keep the pleebs happy too. Service is friendly and accommodating. Ambiance is dark woods and a little divey. Every time I've come here I've had a good time. You probably will too.

Isabella K.
Isabella K.

I've been to Glass Nickel three times, and each experience has been better than the last. The service was iffy the first time I went, but this time it was great. For an appetizer, I highly recommend the toasted ravioli. It's hot and crispy and cheesy and delicious. I've done both a build-your-own pizza and the Chicky Chicky Parm Parm pizza and they were yummy! But the Chicky Chicky Parm Parm is really amazing. It's got both Alfredo and traditional red sauce on it. Truly an exceptional combo. In terms of ambiance, Glass Nickel is a great date night spot. The vibes are just right -- not too loud, and you can find a cozy booth to occupy. I'll definitely be returning to this restaurant in the future.

Savanna B.
Savanna B.

We ordered delivery from Glass Nickel last night. The online ordering process is straightforward and easy. Our pizza arrived piping hot and about an hour before their estimated delivery time which was awesome. The sausage was very good- nice pieces and not spicy, which is important to my sausage loving toddler.

Location

Located in Madison, WI, Glass Nickel Pizza is a popular dining spot that offers a variety of delicious options including salads, pizzas, and sandwiches. With a range of utilities like delivery, takeout, vegan options, and wheelchair accessibility, Glass Nickel Pizza aims to cater to a diverse range of customers.

The menu boasts tempting appetizers and sides such as Cheese Bread, Garlic Bread Sticks, and White Cheddar Cheese Curds. For those looking for something lighter, the Specialty Salads like Acropolis Salad and Caesar Salad are sure to satisfy.

Customers have raved about the quality of the food at Glass Nickel Pizza. Reviews highlight perfectly cooked pizzas, delectable cinna nuggets, and excellent ingredients. The warm and friendly staff, along with the cozy ambiance, make dining at Glass Nickel Pizza a delightful experience.

As a food reviewer, I can attest to the fact that Glass Nickel Pizza truly delivers on flavor and quality. The fresh ingredients, perfectly cooked crust, and generous toppings make each bite a delight. Whether you're a fan of classic pizzas or looking to try something new like the Chicky Chicky Parm Parm, Glass Nickel Pizza has something for everyone.

Overall, Glass Nickel Pizza is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts and food lovers alike. With a wide range of options to choose from, impeccable service, and a welcoming atmosphere, this restaurant is sure to leave a lasting impression.